Return to Home
Advanced Market StructureRef: Trader's Manual

The Trader's Guide to
Futures Specials

Markets are not perfectly efficient. They are constrained by logistics, storage, and math. This document details the structural anomalies—from the "Widowmaker" spread to negative oil—that define alpha and ruin.

Futures Specials Market Structure Infographic
Click to view full screen

The Physics of Time: Term Structure

Understanding the Cost of Carry, Forward Curves, and why 'Rolling' kills returns.

Futures prices are not merely predictions of the future; they are mathematical projections of the spot price based on the Cost of Carry. Arbitrageurs enforce this link. If the future deviates from this cost, risk-free profit exists.

Cost of Carry Model

F(t) = S(t) · e^{(r + u - y)(T - t)}
r: Interest Rate (Cost to borrow cash)u: Storage Cost (Insurance, Tank fees)y: Convenience Yield (Benefit of holding physical)

Deconstructing the Formula

Financials (Gold/Forex)
High 'r', Low 'u'

Price driven by interest rates. Storage is cheap (vaults/electronic).

Physicals (Oil/Grain)
High 'u', Variable 'y'

Price driven by tank space and scarcity. Storage is expensive.

The Mechanics of "The Roll"

Speculators rarely take delivery. Before expiry, they must "Roll" (Close the expiring contract, Open the next month).

Contango Roll
Sell Low (Spot)
Buy High (Future)
= LOSS
Backwardation Roll
Sell High (Spot)
Buy Low (Future)
= PROFIT
Spot PriceFuture PremiumTime to Maturity →

Contango Market Structure

Futures prices are higher than spot. This reflects the cost of storage, insurance, and financing. This is the "normal" state for non-perishable commodities with ample supply.

The "Cash & Carry" Arbitrage

  1. Borrow Cash at rate $r$.
  2. Buy Physical Asset at Spot ($S$).
  3. Sell Futures Contract at ($F$).
  4. Store asset until expiry (Cost $u$).
  5. Deliver asset to settle Future. Pay back loan.
  6. Result: If $F > S + Costs$, you make risk-free money.
Example: VIX Futures (Insurance always costs money), Gold.

The Treasury Complex

Embedded Options, The 'Wildcard', and the anatomy of the Basis Trade.

The Liquidity Smile

The US Treasury Yield Curve is not a smooth line. The most recently issued bonds (On-the-Run) trade at a premium (lower yield) because they are highly liquid. Old bonds (Off-the-Run) trade at a discount.

Theoretical YieldOTR 10Y (Yield Dip)Old 10Y
The Trade

Short OTR (Expensive) / Long OFTR (Cheap). Bet on spread convergence.

The Risk

In a crisis, "Flight to Quality" widens the spread. Everyone wants OTR; nobody wants OFTR.

Essential Commodity Spreads

Processing margins and Inter-market relationships.

Energy

Crack Spread

3:2:1 Ratio

Buy 3 Crude Oil → Sell 2 Gasoline + 1 Heating Oil.

This measures the refining margin. If the spread tightens, refiners slow production, eventually causing product shortages (Gasoline prices rise).

Read More
Agriculture

Crush Spread

Board Crush

Buy Soybeans → Sell Soybean Meal + Soybean Oil.

Measures the profit of processing beans. Meal is for animal feed, Oil is for cooking/biodiesel. Often trades in opposite directions based on Chinese demand vs Energy demand.

Read More
Dangerous

The Widowmaker

March/April Nat Gas

Long March (Winter) / Short April (Spring).

Known for extreme volatility. It bets on how much gas is left in storage at the exact end of winter. It has bankrupted hedge funds (e.g., Amaranth Advisors) due to weather unpredictability.

Read More

The Delivery Timeline

The critical dates where 'Paper' becomes 'Physical'. The danger zone for speculators.

Retail Warning

Most retail brokerages will force liquidate your position 24-48 hours before First Notice Day to prevent accidental delivery.

First Position Day

The "Line in the Sand"

The Margin Hike

Until now, you only needed SPAN margin (e.g., $5,000 to control $100,000 of oil). On Position Day, the exchange (and your broker) realizes you might actually buy the oil. Margin requirement jumps to 100% of the contract value.

Long Holder's Choice

Clearing firms holding Long positions must report their "Long Interest" to the exchange. They basically tell the exchange: "We are staying in."

Physical Delivery Anomalies

When logistics fail: Negative prices in Energy and Power.

WTI Crude Oil (April 2020)

-$37.63

Oil futures require physical delivery at Cushing, Oklahoma. In April 2020, global lockdowns killed demand, and Cushing storage hit 100% capacity. Long holders (ETFs, speculators) had no place to put the oil. They had to PAY buyers to take the contracts off their hands to avoid breaching delivery contracts.

The Lesson

Commodity prices have a "soft floor" (storage costs) and a "hard floor" (zero). But when storage is full, the floor disappears. Prices can theoretically go to negative infinity.

Waha Gas Hub

Natural gas in West Texas is a byproduct of oil drilling. If pipelines break, gas is stranded. Producers will pay -$5.00/MMBtu just to get rid of it (flaring is regulated) so they can keep pumping the profitable oil.

Negative Electricity

Wind farms get tax credits (PTC) for generating. If the credit is $25/MWh, they will happily sell power at -$10/MWh because they still net $15 profit. This forces baseload nuclear/coal plants to pay to stay online.

Agricultural Specials

Quality discounts and the 'Lemon' problem.

The Vomitoxin Discount

In grain markets, futures specs allow for delivery of lower quality grain at a discount. In a bad crop year, only "dirty" wheat (high vomitoxin levels) is available for delivery.

  • Futures track the "dirty" wheat price (low).
  • Cash market needs "clean" wheat (high price).
  • Result: Basis blows out. Hedges fail because the future doesn't protect the value of the clean crop.

Coffee "C" Differentials

The ICE contract allows delivery from 20 countries. Traders will always deliver the cheapest origin allowed (e.g., Honduras vs Colombia).

The "Switch": If exchange differentials don't match real-world prices, certified stocks flood with the "cheapest" beans, dragging the futures price down relative to premium beans used by Starbucks.

Market Microstructure

Gamma squeezes, LME Queues, and Hidden Risks.

Gamma Squeeze

Feedback Loop

When dealers sell Out-of-the-Money (OTM) calls, they are short gamma. As price rises, they must buy futures to hedge. This buying drives price higher, forcing them to buy MORE. This creates an explosive vertical move.

LME Warehouses

Rent Seeking

Warehouses (often owned by banks/traders) intentionally create queues to slow down metal load-out. This generates rent revenue. It disconnects the LME price from the actual physical premium paid for immediate metal.

Stop Hunts

Liquidity Holes

In thin markets (Asian session for US Treasuries), algos may push prices into known areas of liquidity (stop losses) to trigger volume. Once the stops are cleared, price often reverses immediately.

Specials Glossary & Risk Matrix

CategorySpecial NameKey MetricDanger Level
TreasuryRepo SpecialRepo Rate < GCHigh
EnergyNegative PricingStorage Capacity %Critical
AgricultureVomitoxin / QualityQuality SpreadMedium
MicroGamma SqueezeOTM Open InterestVolatile
Nat GasWidowmakerMarch/April SpreadExtreme

Disclaimer: This interface is for educational purposes only. Futures trading involves substantial risk of loss.

Continue Learning